Polski
高速成像中的滚动快门局限性：您需要知道的事项
Utworzono 09.26
In the world of high-speed imaging, capturing fast-moving subjects with clarity is both an art and a science. From sports photography freezing a sprinter’s final stride to industrial cameras monitoring rapid assembly lines, the demand for sharp, accurate high-speed visuals has never been higher. Yet, beneath the surface of many moderncameras```
lies a technology that can undermine even the most careful shot: the rolling shutter.
```
While rolling shutters are common in smartphones, consumercameras, and even some professional gear, their design creates unique challenges in high-speed scenarios. In this guide, we’ll break down how rolling shutters work, their key limitations in high-speed imaging, and why understanding these flaws matters for anyone seeking precision in fast-paced photography or videography.
What Is a Rolling Shutter, and How Does It Differ from a Global Shutter?
To grasp rolling shutter limitations, it’s first essential to understand how they function—especially compared to their more robust counterpart, the global shutter.
A global shutter exposes the entire image sensor at once. When you press the shutter button, every pixel on the sensor captures light simultaneously for the same duration, then stops recording at the same moment. This “all-at-once” approach is ideal for high-speed subjects: it freezes motion uniformly, with no distortion, making it the gold standard for scientific imaging, sports broadcasting, and robotics.
A rolling shutter, by contrast, exposes the sensor sequentially. Instead of capturing the entire frame at once, it scans the sensor line by line (or row by row) from top to bottom (or side to side). Each row of pixels starts and stops recording light at a slightly different time—often just microseconds apart, but enough to create visible artifacts when subjects (or the camera itself) move quickly.
This design is cheaper to manufacture and consumes less power, which is why it’s prevalent in smartphones, DSLRs, and mirrorless cameras aimed at general consumers. For static or slow-moving scenes, rolling shutters work well—you’d likely never notice the difference. But in high-speed imaging, their sequential nature becomes a critical weakness.
Key Limitations of Rolling Shutter in High-Speed Scenarios
In high-speed environments—where subjects move faster than the shutter can scan the sensor—rolling shutters introduce predictable yet problematic distortions. Let’s explore the most common issues and why they occur.
msgid "The “Jello Effect”: Distortion from Camera or Subject Movement" msgstr "“果冻效应”：来自相机或主体运动的失真"
The most recognizable rolling shutter artifact is the jello effect (or jelly effect), named for the way it warps straight lines into wavy, gelatin-like shapes. This occurs when either the camera or the subject moves significantly during the sensor scan.
For example:
• Un utilisateur de smartphone qui filme rapidement une voiture de course remarquera que la carrosserie de la voiture ou l'horizon en arrière-plan se plie comme une vague.
• Un dron que captura una multitud en movimiento rápido puede mostrar las cabezas o los hombros de las personas estirados o sesgados, ya que el movimiento de la cámara supera el escaneo del sensor.
Why does this happen? As the shutter rolls from top to bottom, each row captures the subject at a slightly later time. If the camera or subject shifts position during this scan, the top row records the subject in one place, while the bottom row records it in another. The result is a warped, uneven image that breaks the illusion of a single, frozen moment.
2. Skew and Tilt in Fast-Moving Subjects
When a subject moves horizontally (perpendicular to the rolling shutter’s scan direction), rolling shutters often create skew distortion—making straight, vertical lines appear tilted.
想象一下用滚动快门相机正面拍摄一列高速列车。列车从左向右移动，而快门从上到下扫描。当快门到达传感器的底部行时，列车已经稍微向右移动。列车的顶部与扫描开始时的位置对齐，而底部与结束时的位置对齐——这导致列车看起来倾斜，仿佛它正在转弯。
This effect is particularly problematic in industrial settings, where engineers use high-speed cameras to measure the position or angle of fast-moving parts (e.g., conveyor belts, rotating gears). A skewed image can lead to inaccurate measurements, compromising quality control or safety checks.
3. 部分曝光和运动模糊
In high-speed imaging, even tiny delays matter. Rolling shutters expose each row for the same total duration (e.g., 1/1000th of a second), but because they start sequentially, a fast-moving subject may exit the frame before the scan finishes. This creates partial exposures, where parts of the subject are cut off or blurred.
```
msgid "Consider a bird flying past the camera at high speed. The top rows of the sensor capture the bird in full, but by the time the shutter reaches the bottom rows, the bird has flown out of the frame—leaving the bottom of the image empty or showing only a blurred tail feather."
msgstr "考虑一只鸟以高速飞过相机。传感器的顶部行完整地捕捉到鸟，但当快门到达底部行时，鸟已经飞出了画面——留下图像的底部空白或仅显示模糊的尾羽。"
```
In scientific research—such as the study of insect flight or projectile motion—partial exposures can render data useless. Researchers rely on complete, sharp images to analyze movement patterns, and rolling shutter artifacts introduce variables that skew results.
msgid "4. Inconsistent Lighting in Rapidly Changing Environments" msgstr "4. 环境快速变化中的不一致光照"
Rolling shutters struggle with rapidly changing light sources, such as flickering LED lights, strobes, or sunlight passing through moving foliage. Because each row is exposed at a different time, some rows may capture a bright flash, while others capture the scene in dimmer light—creating banding or uneven brightness across the frame.
This is a common issue in indoor sports photography, where stadium lights often flicker at 50-60Hz (matching electrical grid frequencies). A rolling shutter camera scanning a basketball court may record alternating bright and dark bands, as rows exposed during a light “on” phase appear brighter than those exposed during an “off” phase.
For content creators, this inconsistency ruins the visual flow of a video or series of photos. For engineers using high-speed cameras to monitor machinery under strobe lighting, it can obscure critical details (e.g., a misaligned gear tooth) in dark bands.
5. Rolling Shutter vs. Flash Synchronization
Flash photography relies on precise timing: the flash must fire while the sensor is fully exposed to capture a sharp image. With global shutters, this is straightforward—the entire sensor is active at once, so the flash can fire once for uniform exposure.
Rolling shutters, however, can’t sync with flashes as cleanly. If a flash fires during the scan, only the rows exposed at that exact moment will capture the flash’s light. Rows scanned before or after will be darker, resulting in a partial flash exposure—a bright band across the image, with the rest underexposed.
This limitation is a headache for event photographers shooting fast-paced moments (e.g., a wedding first dance, a concert mosh pit) with flash. Even high-speed flashes struggle to match the rolling shutter’s scan speed, leaving images with uneven lighting.
When Do These Limitations Matter Most?
Rolling shutter artifacts aren’t always problematic—context is key. They become most noticeable (and costly) in scenarios where:
• Sujets se déplacent à des vitesses extrêmes : Pensez aux voitures de course, aux balles ou aux objets en chute.
• Les caméras se déplacent rapidement : Des exemples incluent des séquences de drones, des prises de vue d'action à main levée ou des caméras montées sur des véhicules en mouvement.
• La precisión es crítica: La investigación científica, la inspección industrial o el análisis de movimiento dependen de datos precisos y no distorsionados.
• Luz inestable: Los entornos con luces parpadeantes o cambios rápidos de luz exageran el banding.
In contrast, for static portraits, landscape photography, or slow-moving videos (e.g., a cooking tutorial), rolling shutters perform perfectly well—their limitations are all but invisible.
Mitigating Rolling Shutter Limitations: Workarounds and Solutions
While rolling shutters can’t match global shutters for high-speed accuracy, there are ways to reduce their impact:
• Utilisez des vitesses d'obturation plus rapides : Des temps d'exposition plus courts minimisent la fenêtre de mouvement pendant le scan, réduisant ainsi la distorsion. Par exemple, une exposition de 1/4000 de seconde laisse moins de temps à un sujet pour se déplacer qu'une exposition de 1/500 de seconde.
• Stabiliser la caméra : Les trépieds, les stabilisateurs ou les supports fixes réduisent le mouvement de la caméra, une cause majeure de l'effet gélatineux.
• Evite el paneo con sujetos rápidos: En lugar de mover la cámara para seguir a un sujeto, deje que el sujeto se mueva a través de un marco estático.
• Post-processing tools: Software like Adobe Premiere Pro or DaVinci Resolve offers rolling shutter correction filters, which can reduce skew or jello effects (though results vary and may introduce slight blurring).
• Upgrade to a global shutter camera: For professional or scientific use, investing in a global shutter camera eliminates these issues entirely—though they come with a higher price tag.
The Future of Rolling Shutter in High-Speed Imaging
As technology advances, manufacturers are finding ways to minimize rolling shutter flaws. New sensor designs, such as electronic rolling shutters with faster scan rates, reduce the time between row exposures, making artifacts less noticeable. Some smartphones now advertise “global shutter modes” for video, though these often use software tricks rather than true global shutter hardware.
对于大多数消费者来说，卷帘将仍然是常态——它们的成本和能效太有价值，无法完全替代。但对于精度至关重要的行业来说，全球快门（以及像堆叠传感器这样的新兴替代品）将继续获得市场份额。
Conclusion: Conheça o seu obturador para melhores resultados em alta velocidade
Rolling shutters are a double-edged sword: they make high-quality cameras affordable and accessible, but their sequential scanning creates unique challenges in fast-moving scenarios. From jello effects to skewed measurements, these limitations can compromise everything from a sports photo to critical scientific data.
By understanding how rolling shutters work and when their flaws become problematic, you can make smarter choices—whether you’re selecting a camera, adjusting your shooting technique, or investing in post-processing tools. For casual use, rolling shutters are more than sufficient. But when speed and accuracy are non-negotiable, recognizing their limitations is the first step toward capturing the sharp, reliable images you need.
Kontakt
Podaj swoje informacje, a skontaktujemy się z Tobą.
WhatsApp
WeChat